Dear Readers: So what do you think? Laura Ann Arnold

Original story: http://www.indystar.com/article/20120225/BUSINESS/302250002/State-energy-adviser-Brandon-Seitz-takes-job-utility-raising-concerns-among-watchdog-groups?odyssey=nav|head

Written by John Russell, 12:10 AM, Feb. 25, 2012

Lt. Gov. Becky Skillman's top energy policy adviser has taken a job with a major Indiana utility, raising more questions about the closeness of the Daniels administration and the energy companies it regulates.

Brandon Seitz, who had been director of Indiana's Office of Energy Development, started his new job Monday as manager of regulatory affairs for the Northern Indiana Public Service Co., or NIPSCO.

In his new role, Seitz will work on NIPSCO rate issues in front of the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission and the Office of Utility Consumer Counselor. The utility provides electricity and natural gas to hundreds of thousands in Northern Indiana.

Some government watchdog groups said the move raised alarms, coming on the heels of an ethics scandal involving another major utility, Duke Energy, and state utility regulators.

That scandal, which began when Duke hired the state's top regulatory attorney while he was handling Duke cases, cost four people their jobs and led to felony indictments against the former chairman of the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission.

Under Indiana law, state employees who want to move to private industry must wait through a 365-day "cooling-off" period if they were involved personally and substantially with issues affecting the company.

The state ethics panel ruled that Seitz's employment with NIPSCO did not violate state law. In a six-page ruling, the panel pointed out that Seitz's office in state government did not regulate or license any utility. The panel also said that based on information from Seitz and his agency's ethics officer, NIPSCO's offer of employment did not result "from information of a confidential nature."

In addition, the panel found that Seitz did not have a financial interest in the outcome of any matter between NIPSCO and the state, and the company did not have any contracts with Seitz's office. Nor would Seitz be working as an executive branch lobbyist, seeking to influence state government on policy, it said.

"None of the facts provided suggest that NIPSCO's offer of employment to Mr. Seitz was extended in an attempt to influence him in his capacity as Director," the ethics report said.

But Kerwin Olson, executive director of watchdog group Citizen Action Coalition of Indiana, said Seitz was part of a team that formulated energy policy in Indiana, and therefore should do everything to avoid the possibility of a conflict of interest.

"It seems pretty murky," he said.

Julia Vaughn, policy director for Common Cause/Indiana, said a conflict might still exist due to the energy issues involved, not just which agency Seitz worked in.

"The Ethics Commission must still be handing out waivers to the cooling-off period like Halloween candy," she said.

As director of the Indiana Office of Energy Development, Seitz had offered advice on energy programs, services and initiatives to the administration of Gov. Mitch Daniels. The OED does not have any regulatory or licensing authority. Seitz had worked for the office since 2005.

He referred questions to NIPSCO's public relations office. A NIPSCO spokesman, Nick Meyer, said Seitz had not worked as a state regulator, only a policy adviser.

"As a state employee, he had no role in approving our cases or filings in front of the commission," Meyer said, adding that Seitz would be a "great addition to our team, given his unique perspective and background."

Call Star reporter John Russell at (317) 444-6283. Follow him on Twitter: @johnrussell99.

Dear Readers: I received this message as an email yesterday. Laura Ann Arnold

Indiana Office of Energy Development Energy Office Has New Director Lt. Governor Becky Skillman has announced Brandon Seitz is leaving his   position as director of the Office of Energy Development (OED) to serve in   the private sector. Tristan Vance has   been appointed to the position, effective February 20. “Where we once lagged far behind, Indiana has become a leader in producing   homegrown energy. Brandon’s efforts helped us grow as fast as any state in   the areas of wind power, biofuels, clean coaland more,” Lt. Governor Skillman   said.  “I’m confident Tristan Vance will continue fostering success in   this high-potential sector of our economy.” Seitz joined Lt. Governor Skillman’s executive staff in 2005 after a prior   stint on staff in the Indiana  House of Representatives. He has worked   in various capacities at OED and for Lt. Governor Skillman, including deputy   chief of staff. He was appointed director of OED in 2008. Vance previously worked as special assistant to the Lt. Governor starting in   2005. After a stint at the Office of Community and Rural Affairs, he joined   the Government Efficiency and Financial Planning group in the Office of   Management and Budget in 2007. There, he monitored efficiency at several   state agencies, including OED. Vance is from Paoli, and is a graduate of   Hanover College. Contact Us Indiana Office of   Energy Development One North Capitol Suite 600 Indianapolis, IN   46074 (317) 232-8939 Follow us on   twitter: IndianaEnergy       Februrary, 2012 OED Director Tristan Vance "I am very pleased to be working with the Office of Energy Development on Indiana's energy future," says OED Director Tristan Vance.  "There are so many opportunities ahead of us to continue to develop Indiana as a leader in homegrown energy." Seitz Moves to Private Sector Following a long stint in the public sector,former OED Director Brandon Seitz will move to the other side of the energy business.  Seitz is now working in regulatory affairs for Nisource. You can contact Brandon via email at bseitz-at-nisource.com